Skip to content
ndb217's profile

New problem solver

 • 

41 Messages

Mon, Aug 10, 2020 9:00 PM

Another broken dhcpv6-pd complaint on brand new DPC3939B

I, too, am having the prefix delegation neighbor discovery issue noted in this post. My Cisco DPC3939B modem worked flawlessly for years but a few months ago started randomly rebooting. I expected the PD to change since the DUID requesting the prefix would be different, but what I did not expect is that IPv6 would stop working cimnpletely. 90% of my traffic is v6 (yes, I have tracked it for years), and now the entire network is a dunpster fire since I no longer have any IPv6 connectivity. My router does not support ndp-proxy, so I am now stuck with a completely broken network. I would have suffered through the rancom reboots had I known this would have been the result of a CPE replacement. My old one must have had an older firmware build, as there are some other subtle differences - but I need this fixed, a pretty big part of my job involves working with IPv6 and this complete lack of it is literally costing me productivity. 

Responses

Official Employee

 • 

508 Messages

7 m ago

Thanks so much for taking the time to reach out to us through our business forums. I very much appreciate your patience and greatly apologize for the delay in our response. I know how important the services are to your business and we want to do all that we can to assist. I know how impactful any service issue is to your business as I use my connection daily for business purposes. I would love to get to the bottom of the IPV6 issues and help you get back to business as usual. Can you please reach out through private message with your first and last name, business service address and account number or phone number? 

New problem solver

 • 

41 Messages

7 m ago

Sure, message sent.

Official Employee

 • 

235 Messages

7 m ago

Thank you for your patience and for sending us that private message! We will continue in assisting you from there.

Contributor

 • 

19 Messages

7 m ago

The best I managed so far was to set up a script to automatically reboot the modem every day.  That sort of works except that the network is offline for the ten minutes it takes to reboot and sometimes the modem doesn't actually come back up on its own.

Contributor

 • 

19 Messages

7 m ago

Go figure, Comcast went and locked my thread prior to achieving any resolution.  That's not how community forums are supposed to work!  *sigh*

New problem solver

 • 

41 Messages

7 m ago

At this point I will likely be switching to bridge mode until this can be remedied, I need some kind of native IPv6 more than I need static IPv4. I'll have to work around whatever limits I have there, and do without the externally available stuff I had prior - maybe move it to ZeroTier or something.

I am out of contract and JUST requested a new one be generated. I will not be signing until I have a positive resolution on this issue. 

Official Employee

 • 

508 Messages

7 m ago

I can truly understand how important this service is to your business and we are going to work to ensure that we get this resolved for you. I appreciate your patience and all the time you are delgating out of your day to assist us with this. I will continue to reach out through our private message with you so we can continue to work to get this resolved. 

Contributor

 • 

17 Messages

6 m ago

I moved some of my stuff to Hurricane Electric for IPv6... its not as fast (extra hops) but it works and it is static.

Contributor

 • 

19 Messages

6 m ago

That's a bummer.  Unfortunately it doesn't seem like the Tier 2 support people talk much to each other.  So even though we're all having the same problems with IPv6 routing and prefix delegation, they aren't comparing notes on the back-end or testing their hypotheses before applying changes to consumer equipment.

 

For example, the support team just downgraded my gateway's firmware and it broke IPv6 routing completely.  I have to assume that the same thing would have happened in the lab had anyone tried it.

 

I would really like to close the loop with a programmer on the software team who has direct insight into the modem's internal operation and who is able to be more methodical about reproducing and debugging these common issues.

Official Employee

 • 

136 Messages

6 m ago

I truly apologize that this has been your experience. I am going to set up a follow up for tomorrow morning as our Advance Repair Team should be in the office and available for an update. I can't thank you enough for your patience and willingness to work with us. I know that certain conditions may take more time resolve. However, we will continue to own this issue and work together to get to the bottom of this. 

New problem solver

 • 

41 Messages

6 m ago

The saga continues, I ended up doing a whole bunch of stuff. 
I was told in no uncertain terms that the modem they replaced my old one with will never do v6 correctly, I won't say how or from who, but I trust this source. So, I canceled my static IPs, replaced my cable modem with the one I bought (an Arris SB8200). That broke v6 in so much that it only seems to support one /64, which is functionally useless to me. I did almost no troubleshooting and can’t find any docs on it, it doesn’t seem to be configurable that I can find. Calling comcast yielded no useful results as they "can't see into that modem in bridge mode", so they can't help. OK, fine. It's not worth the time to argue, and since there are zero configuration options on that modem that I can find, I'll switch back. 
I switched back to the comcast modem. That took about 2 hours last night to get them to at least pretend to understand what I was talking about. Re-provisioning the old modem got me v4 again. v6 takes forever to provision, for whatever reason, but does eventually finish after about 20 minutes. This device also has some serious stability issues in that I have to hard reset it about every 5 days, which is not acceptable for what I pay for this service.

Going back through my notes from 5+ years ago, I found that when you request a static IP a level2 tech has to call you, so, I called and had them re-add a single static ipv4 address, which they called me to provision the next day around 8am. Once I had that, I set it back to bridge mode and I am back to dynamic everything working. At this point v6 is still broken, so I told the level2 tech my issue and he offered to replace the puma based modem with a CGA4131COM. What do I have to lose at this point?

IPv6, apparently. 

This modem delegated me a /59 once, which didn't work and seems broken in the same way as the last modem, but at least doesn't have the same stability issues as the last device.  At this point I am now 100% without IPv6 connectivity. Even in bridge mode the behavior is totally broken, I get no ipv6, period. Part of the issue appears to be that the WAN Default Gateway Address (IPv6): within the comcast modem seems to take forever to populate (typically done via a RA). 

 

Come on, this is almost comically bad at this point. Maybe we should do a youtube "historical fiction" comedy about this process. Youtube is totally dial stacked, we could stream it totally over v6....unless, of course, you have comcast business service. 

 

 

 

New problem solver

 • 

41 Messages

6 m ago

This seems like a problem. The blacked out areas all look normal and correct. This is on a CGA4131COM that was installed this morning. The lack of a v6 next-hop is pretty telling as to why nothing works. Screen Shot 2020-08-29 at 2.45.41 PM.png

Official Employee

 • 

508 Messages

6 m ago

Hello, I just wanted to take some time and reach out to you and check in. Has there been any change with the IPV6 routing issue? Have you heard from our advanced repair teams at all? 

New problem solver

 • 

41 Messages

6 m ago

Only after removing and then re-adding static addressing did I ever hear from an advanced support person, so not because of my actual issue, but yes.
I was assured that my problem would be solved by adding the new device as noted in my post above, as of now I have zero ipv6 capability. So no, my problem has not been solved, IPv6 is now totally broken.

Official Employee

 • 

508 Messages

6 m ago

Thanks so much for taking the time to reach out to us through our business forums. I very much appreciate your patience and greatly apologize for the delay in our response. I know how important the services are to your business and we want to do all that we can to assist. I rely on my connection daily and I can understand how frustrating it is that the services are not meeting your expectations. I would love to assist with the IPV6 issues that you are experiencing and get you back into working abilities. Can you please reach out through private message with your first and last name, business service address and account number or phone number?